Five Key Themes of the American Identity

From the lecture series: The History of the United States, 2nd Edition

By Gary W. Gallagher, Ph.D., University of Virginia; Patrick N. Allitt, Ph.D., Emory University; and Allen C. Guelzo, Ph.D., Gettysburg College

The story of the United States contains knaves and nobility, cads and crusaders, and enough turbulence to upset entire governments. And while it may appear that the nation is built on constant change, there do exist constant themes that have helped to define our American identity.

Document text "We the People" of the preamble to the United States constitution with american flag in background
(Image: Charles Brutlag/Shutterstock)

These key themes of American identity serve as the melody for our history, and provide a narrative that helps us make sense of all the changes our country has seen.

1. Passion for Freedom

Now,  certainly one thing which has been a continuing notion in the midst  of the changes in American history has been the American passion for freedom. That freedom has taken many different forms—political, religious, economic—and it’s involved some very high-stakes risks; it hasn’t been a foregone conclusion. Sometimes, in the case of the New England Puritans, the freedom people have been searching for in America has been the freedom to be un-free, in other words, the freedom to impose a new sense of order on a world that they found too chaotic and disorganized.

This is a transcript from the video series The History of the United States, 2nd Edition. Watch it now, on The Great Courses Plus.

2. Pursuit of Education

flags of Department of Education
Education has been the classic American form of the opportunity to make of yourself whatever you wish (Image: danielo/Shutterstock)

In whatever form, however, the search for freedom has been a fundamental urge at every point in American history, from the Pilgrims to the civil rights movement. Another basic theme has been the pursuit of education. This is actually linked to the pursuit of freedom, because once you’ve torn yourself away from the various kinds of un-freedom in the past, then it’s up to you to fashion a new American identity for yourself. Education has been the classic American form of the opportunity to make of yourself whatever you wish.

Learn more about the “American System”

3. Faith in Popular Government

A third theme that shows up everywhere in American life is an unquestioned faith in the value of popular government. Call it democracy, call it republicanism, call it what you will. Americans have never seriously doubted the right of people to rule themselves. It sometimes seems that we as Americans fight politically with each other like wild animals, but we’ve never  fought  over  whether  we  should  become  a  monarchy or whether it would be a good idea to have a dictator. That’s the moment when Americans immediately forget the issues they were fighting over, and start fighting you, if what you’re trying to do is impose a dictatorship or a monarchy or any other form of government that is not government of the people, by the people, and for the people.

Learn more about how Congress took control of Reconstruction policy

4. Willingness to Experiment

A fourth theme running through all of our lectures and through all of American history has been the really tremendous willingness of Americans to experiment with new things. Living in a new environment, in a new world, in a new continent, with new rules to govern their conduct, the American identity has always shown a kind of forward-looking-ness, a special welcome to the new and the untried. They don’t feel constrained by the habits of other peoples or of other times. That’s something that shows up especially in the ease with which Americans have assimilated wave upon wave upon wave of immigrants from a bewildering variety of backgrounds.

Learn more about a place where European ideas of society no longer applied

5. American Exceptionalism

The last theme really builds on the other four. Americans have traditionally believed that, as a nation, that we are like nothing else the world has ever seen before. We are exceptional. We  are  exemplary. We are a “city on a hill.” The American identity is linked to the first large-scale democratic republic in human history, and we made it work. While other nations were busy butchering each other over whether or not the Psalms should be sung in Latin or sung in French, we created a system of religious tolerance that put away the old religious conflicts of the past.

We also opened up our economic and political system to anyone with the brains and the talent to make a way forward, and we looked to things like that, not to the characteristics of hereditary aristocracy, but to people who had that brains, had that talent, and were willing to put it to risk. That’s what we have taken as our models.

Sometimes this sense of exceptionalism, this sense of being something different, something entirely apart from what the rest of the world has done or been in the past, can degenerate. It can degenerate into a kind of smug self-congratulation, or even self-righteousness, not just that we’re different from others, but that we’re better because we’re different from others. This sentiment is what frequently grates on the ears of other peoples of other nations. Most of the time, however, that sense of being exceptional has also given to Americans a sense of having a national mission, that what we are doing as a nation is not only different, but it’s done not just for us, but for the rest of the world, that our country is worth loving, as Abraham Lincoln once said, not just because it is our country, but because it is a country of the free.

It is a country committed to a certain set of ideas, built around not a certain race or a certain ethnicity, but around a political document, the U.S. Constitution, and a constellation of political ideas captured really for the first time in our Declaration of Independence.

That brings us back, as in a big circle, to that deep-seated passion for freedom, a passion that we can find present in American life and American experience almost from the first moment that we can begin to think of ourselves as something different from Europe, as a nation or the beginnings of a nation, back, in fact, all the way to the moment when, in the year 1492, a Genoese entrepreneur and navigator named Christopher Columbus caught his first glimpse of the island shores of what was, for him at least, a new world.

Learn more about the New World Order

Common Questions About American Identity

Q: What is American culture?

American culture is the result of European culture shaped by Native American, African, Latino, and Asian culture. A sense of righteousness, a can-do attitude, and maximum profit business are key counterparts to the American aesthetic.

Q: What are the primary religions of the USA?

Almost 3/4 of all Americans are some variant of Christianity. The other religions vary with the region. Buddhists largely make up the West while Islam reigns in the South and Mid-West. Judaism rules in the Northeast.

Q: What is America most famous for?

America is known the world over for being the most dominant military and economic power as well as for worldwide entertainment trends and fast food.

Q: What food defines American culture?

Aside from the Thanksgiving tradition of roasted turkey, brown gravy, dressing, green beans and cranberry sauce, each region has its own distinctly popular foods. In the south, it’s mashed potatoes, cornbread, fried oysters, and steak. In the Northeast, it’s clam chowder and boiled crabs. In the West, it’s vegetarian food and burgers. In the Midwest, it’s lake trout and cheese.

This article was updated on 7/24/2019

Keep Reading
A Love Letter from George Washington
Washington, City of Scandal
Immigrant Cuisines and Ethnic Restaurants