Why Has Sherlock Holmes Remained So Popular Over the Years?

From a Lecture Series presented by Professor Patrick Allitt, Ph.D.

Sherlock Holmes popularized criminology and forensics investigating in a time when fingerprinting was brand-new. How has Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s impossibly perceptive detective stood the test of time?

Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson. Published in The Adventure of Silver Blaze, which appeared in The Strand Magazine in December 1892, with the caption "HOLMES GAVE ME A SKETCH OF THE EVENTS.
Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson. Published in The Adventure of Silver Blaze, which appeared in The Strand Magazine in December 1892, with the caption “HOLMES GAVE ME A SKETCH OF THE EVENTS.
The cover page of Beeton's Christmas Annual issue which contains Holmes's first appearance in 1887 (A Study in Scarlet).
The cover page of Beeton’s Christmas Annual issue which contains Holmes’s first appearance in 1887 (A Study in Scarlet).

As the reading public got bigger, and more people were able to read and wanted to read, more niches were established in the literary market. It was in the late 1880s that Conan Doyle created the Sherlock Holmes phenomenon. He was Scottish, and he was a struggling young doctor living first in Portsmouth on the south coast, then moving up to London. Like many aspiring doctors, he didn’t really have enough patients. Very often he would while away a day waiting for patients to come, and they didn’t. In the meantime, he passed the time by writing fiction, and in the late ’80s, in 1886, he wrote A Study in Scarlet, which is the first of the Sherlock Holmes books. He sold it outright to a publisher for £25.

The Holmes character was based on one of his Edinburgh medical professors, Dr. Joseph Bell. Joseph Bell had specialized in simply being able to look at somebody and being able to tell from how they appeared what their job was and where they came from and where they had been recently. Sherlock Holmes elevates that skill to preternatural heights. For example, the very first time he meets Dr. Watson, he says “Ah, an army doctor who has just been in Afghanistan, I see.” Watson is astonished at this incredibly accurate reading of his own character.

Learn more: Late Victorian Literature

Holmes represented the triumph of scientific criminology, the idea that if you were to investigate minutely with your looking glass and your little chemical experiments, you can get much further than the police do with their traditional methods. The London police by then already had a lot of failures to their credit—failures to make the appropriate arrest, partly because the police mainly responded on knowing who was doing what in the London underworld—and the lure of Holmes’ detection is that he goes underneath the obvious to look for little clues which give him crucial information about the actual culprits. Lestrade, the regular policeman, isn’t ever quite good enough. Holmes is the one who gets to the bottom of these matters.

He studies the history of crime, looking for parallels to each new one. One thing he says to Watson is “There is no such thing as a new crime. They just go on again and again. Look for the parallels and you will find the perpetrator.” He is supposed to have written a monograph of 140 types of tobacco which he can recognize by scent and chemical analysis. He is moody. He is a violin player, a cocaine addict who goes into big depressions between cases and then comes surging up again. Watson himself, the bumbling but plucky sidekick, is a masterpiece, and much of the fun of the story comes out of the conversations between the two of them.

This is a transcript from the video series Victorian Britain. It’s available for audio and video download here.

This is just the period in which fingerprinting was being developed, and Holmes himself is a great advocate of fingerprinting, which did become a standard police method. First of all, Conan Doyle was delighted by the success of Sherlock Holmes. The first series, he was given £35 per story, once the phenomenon started to catch on. The Strand magazine offered him £50 per story when at first he was reluctant to write another series. At the end of the second series, he killed off Holmes altogether. He is wrestling with Moriarty at the edge of the Reichenbach Falls, and they both plunge into the river and are lost. His audience was horrified at the loss of their great hero because you know what it is like when you are reading a hero story. The hero doesn’t die. That is the first principle. Finally, he was offered such an enormous financial incentive (an American magazine had offered him £5,000 per story. This is after he sold the original one outright for £25.) So, with that kind of incentive, Holmes came back. He hadn’t really died there in the river after all. Altogether, he wrote four novels and five sets of these short stories, in 1897 a stage play based on the Holmes adventures, and of course it has become a staple of movies and TV since then.

Portrait of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle by Herbert Rose Barraud, 1893
Portrait of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle by Herbert Rose Barraud, 1893

Conan Doyle was very widely admired. He did real sleuthing work of his own. People with mysteries of various kinds would often consult him, saying, “Tell me, as the creator of Sherlock Holmes, what you think is really happening.” Occasionally, he was able to sort out mysteries. He also became an advocate for people who he thought had been wrongly condemned either to prison or to death and was able to achieve some reprieves for wrongly convicted men.

So, there we are. It is strange and so typical that what at first looked like an extremely ephemeral literature ended up having great staying power right up to the present, which none of his contemporaries, including the author himself, could possibly foresee.

Keep Reading:
Late Victorian Literature: Oscar Wilde and the Aesthetic Movement
Late Victorian Literature: Thomas Hardy’s Bleak England

From the Lecture Series: Victorian Britain
Taught by Professor Patrick N. Allitt 
Images Courtesy of:
Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson, By Sidney Paget (1860-1908) (Strand Magazine) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Breeton’s Christmas Annual 1887, David Henry Friston [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Arthur Conan Doyle, 1893, By Herbert Rose Barraud (1845 – c1896) (Bonhams) [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons