Military Tactics of WWI: The Failure of the Schlieffen Plan

From a lecture series presented by Professor Vejas Gabriel Liulevicius

Developed long before the war itself, the German Schlieffen Plan was part of an extensive military preparation. Unfortunatley, it was doomed to fail.

Map of operations on the frontiers for the article on the Schlieffen Plan
Map of operations on the frontiers

The Schlieffen Plan

Photo of Alfred von Schlieffen, 1906
Alfred von Schlieffen, 1906

Developed long before the war itself, the German Schlieffen Plan was part of an extensive military preparation.

Learn more: The Origins of World War I

The man who had crafted it was the German general chief of staff, General Alfred von Schlieffen. He was chief of staff from 1891 to 1905 and excelled precisely at careful preparation and thinking in abstract terms about the military challenge that Germany’s geopolitical position represented.

Simply put, Germany’s geopolitical challenge was the possibility of war on two fronts simultaneously. At the center of Europe, it might find itself forced to fight against both France in the west and Russia in the east.

Schlieffen’s plan was a sweeping, bold conception of how to achieve victory in a two-front war. Essentially, speed would be of the essence: by first very quickly destroying France, and then turning on the Russian great power, a country that would be expected to be slower to mobilize and more ponderous in its preparations for war.

The Schlieffen Plan disregarded the political implications of what was regarded as essentially a technical solution to a military problem. It called for the violation of Belgian and Dutch neutrality by invading both those countries to achieve surprise in a vast attack on France.

A huge German force would come swinging through northern France after invading Belgium and Holland, arcing around Paris in order to achieve decisive victory within a timetable of about six weeks. It was hoped that Paris itself would be surrounded—French armies and French leadership—and that this would represent a military masterpiece, a battle of annihilation.

Learn more: Imperial Rivalry—1870–1914

The Schlieffen Plan’s emphasis was thus on a huge concentration of force on the right wing, whereby German movement would come plunging through northern France. After von Schlieffen died, this plan was further worked on and altered by Helmuth von Moltke, his successor.

Von Moltke changed certain aspects of the plan. He did not solve the political problem of violating neutrality, but he lessened it by declining to invade Holland. He also took troops away from the vast movement that was projected for the invasion of northern France; he instead drew off some of those troops to the Eastern Front and others for the defense of the territory of Lorraine to the south.

Learn more: World War I: Destruction and Rebirth

The French Plan 

Image of Joseph Joffre, French Marshal, CiC of French Army in 1914
Joseph Joffre, French Marshal, CiC of French Army in 1914

At precisely the same time the Schlieffen Plan was put into action, the opposite plan, the French Plan XVII, was enacted.

The French plan, endorsed by commander Joseph Joffre, called for an all-out attack into Germany to regain the lost territories of Alsace-Lorraine, avenging the humiliating defeat of 1871, and redeeming French honor. Stressing the “cult of the offensive,” Plan XVII tended to underestimate German reserves that could be deployed in the defense of these territories and, in a very real sense, played into the expectations of the Schlieffen Plan.

An attack of the south would ensure what the German planners hoped for: that their sweeping movement would capture even more French troops. In practice, however, both plans broke down in disaster.

Hello reader! You could be getting much more from this article by watching its accompanying video lecture on The Great Courses Plus! Click here for information on pricing plans, and to start your free trial.

Plan XVII , which was launched on August 14, broke against German defenses in Lorraine and suffered enormous losses. The fate of the Schlieffen Plan proceeded a little more positively at first and seemed to be succeeding, but then it broke down in what afterward was called the “Miracle of the Marne” by French patriots, a truly remarkable moment of salvation and national mobilization to expel the German invader.

Learn more: World War I

The Invasion of Belguim 

On August 4, German troops invaded Belgium. They moved through Belgium, then plunged into France. By early September they had reached the Marne River, some 20 miles from Paris.

It is said that German advance troops could see the Eiffel Tower in the distance. The German advance, however, had been slowed, with the Schlieffen Plan running behind schedule at crucial moments. The German advance had been hampered by fiercer Belgian resistance than had been anticipated—as well as by the destruction of railroads and other strategic assets by the Belgians or the French—and also slowed by German anxieties about the fear of snipers.

Image of Belgian troops, with machine-guns pulled by dogs, photographed during the Battle of the Frontiers
Belgian troops, with machine-guns pulled by dogs, photographed during the Battle of the Frontiers

Nonetheless, there were remarkable and celebrated successes that gave a sense of optimism about the enacting of the Schlieffen Plan. On August 7, the main citadel of Liege, a key strategic point that was supposed to hold up the German advance, was captured.

Heavy German guns were brought up to demolish other forts, and soon this resistance was quelled. This represented, it seemed to some, the triumph of military technology over old-style fortifications, a success, it seemed, for the cult of the offensive. As German armies approached Paris, the French government packed up and fled to Bordeaux.

Nonetheless, Paris was to be defended, and indeed the bridges of Paris were mined in preparation for blowing them up in case the German troops reached the capital. At the same time, another factor came into play that had not been expected to come into play quite so soon. The British Expeditionary Force, or the BEF, as it was called,mobilized quickly and was thrown into battle in northern France. The British forces moved forward and reached Mons.

Learn more: The Impact of World War I—New World Disorder

600 Taxicabs to the Rescue 

Upon discovering that they were overextended and in peril of being simply overwhelmed by the German advance, both British and French forces moved back in a fast retreat, seeking a place to make a concerted stand.

In the process of the German advance, as the Schlieffen Plan continued to move through the stages of its prospective sections, it was discovered that a gap had opened up between the advancing German armies, between the First Army under General von Kluck and the Second Army under General von Bülow.

This became a concern, and the result was that the German armies moved closer together. The German armies, in an alteration of the plan, thus did not come around Paris to encircle it, but instead began their inward turn that had been projected for the Schlieffen Plan, further east. The result strategically was that the German armies had left their flanks exposed to Paris itself, not expecting that Paris would be the site of considerable resistance or military peril.

Photo of French Infantry charging, 1914
French Infantry charge, 1914

This was the opportunity the allies had been waiting for. French and British forces counterattacked on the Marne from September 6 to 10, 1914. They were aided in this by a heroic and legendary effort, which was celebrated ever afterward, as hundreds of taxicabs—600 of them, to be precise—brought troops that had been stationed in Paris from Paris itself all the way out to the battlefield, shuttling these men back and forth to get them to the places where they needed to be.

Clearly the taxicabs and their forces were not the sole decisive element here, but it certainly gives a sense of the heroism that was involved in this mobilization to expel the invader. Following an order from Colonel Hentsch, German forces fell back to the Aisne River and began to dig in. This was a crucial moment, as it was admission that the Schlieffen Plan had ultimately not succeeded, and it was also the beginning of trench warfare.

Keep Reading:
The Great Powers of World War I—Germany’s Revolution
Learning French Manners and Culture
War, Nutritionism, and the Great Depression

From the Lecture Series: World War I: The Great War
Taught by Professor Vejas
Gabriel Liulevicius, Ph.D.
Images Courtesy of:
Count Alfred von Schlieffen in 1906, By Photo studio E. Bieber – https://www2.landesarchiv-bw.de/ofs21/bild_zoom/zoom.php, PD-US, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=45580105
Battle of the Frontiers Map, By Lvcvlvs (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.